What’s the difference between conservatives and reactionaries?
In short:
A conservative wants to preserve the status quo (or change it slowly).
A reactionary wants to reverse progress and return to a previous order β often an idealized or mythologized past.
The Core Difference:
Conservative | Reactionary |
---|---|
Wants to conserve existing institutions, traditions, and social order. | Wants to restore a past order β often rejecting modernity altogether. |
Accepts some gradual change if necessary to preserve stability. | Sees recent changes (modernization, liberalization) as corruptions that must be undone. |
May negotiate with progress or adapt slowly. | Opposes progress on principle β progress is the problem. |
Historical Example:
Conservative:
β Edmund Burke opposed the French Revolution, but didnβt want to destroy parliamentary government. He wanted to preserve traditions and institutions to prevent chaos.
Reactionary:
β Joseph de Maistre welcomed authoritarian monarchy and theocracy after the French Revolution, believing divine right rule was the only cure for societal decay.
In Modern Terms:
- A conservative in America might say: “We shouldnβt rush into sweeping changes β we need to preserve family values, religious freedom, and limited government.”
- A reactionary might say: “Modern society is degenerate. We need to abolish democracy, bring back monarchy or biblical law, and return to the way things were before feminism, secularism, or civil rights.”
Where It Gets Tricky:
Many reactionaries call themselves conservatives β especially in American politics β because βreactionaryβ is usually a pejorative term today.
But ideologically:
- Conservatives = cautious, incremental, defensive of the present order.
- Reactionaries = revanchist, nostalgic, hostile to modernity.
In Summary:
All reactionaries are right-wing extremists, but not all conservatives are reactionaries.
Conservatives defend the status quo.
Reactionaries want to roll back history.
Spectrum of Political Attitudes Towards Change
Position | Attitude Toward Change | View of the Past | View of the Future | Examples |
---|---|---|---|---|
Radical / Revolutionary | Overthrow existing system | Irrelevant or oppressive past | Build something entirely new | Anarchists, Communists, Revolutionaries |
Progressive / Liberal | Reform existing system | Learn from past mistakes | Improve society incrementally | Social Democrats, Democratic Socialists, Liberals |
Conservative | Preserve system as-is or allow very slow change | Respect traditions | Stability is more important than change | Traditional Conservatives, Libertarians (sometimes) |
Reactionary | Undo modern changes, return to past order | The past was better / pure | Restore lost greatness | Christian Nationalists, Monarchists, Theocrats, Fascists |
Comments are closed.